Doctor Who is a good show… it just isn’t GREAT anymore. And this isn’t just me being bitter about Ten (my Doctor) not being the current Doctor. I like Eleven. He’s great. I like Amy. She’s hot and sassy. But this run just isn’t as good.
The writing is sloppy. Long established rules and facts about the series have been ignored left and right. Paradoxes exist in almost every main-arch episode when (according to long established rules) this should destroy the universe.
And nothing new is used any more! Wasn’t there a time when the answer to every single mystery wasn’t “River Song,” or “perception filter”? I mean it’s always River and it’s never not a perception filter!
And why the fuck are Amy and Rory so not bothered about the losing there baby thing anymore? Yeah, you grew up with your daughter. Yes, you turned her from her psycho-kill-the-doctor ways. But you still never got to raise your child… at least be a little bit gloomy!
And my biggest problem: The plot and character development.
It’s shit these days. Know that twenty min period where we got to see the psycho-kill-the-doctor Melody? And then she was suddenly not evil. Why the fuck wasn’t that stretched out to last a season?! That was a bitching character and the development from psycho to not-psycho was instant.
The new series seriously lacks character development. Hell, Rory’s pretty much the only character who is actually growing. And it’s only seen through the comedy. Apparently Moffat only likes to develop thoughtfully through humor.
At this point, I don’t care who kills the doctor, or who River kills, or what happens to Amy, or how Rory will die next. And this is the major problem. I don’t care. How could this have happened? How could I possibly not care about something that has been so damn important to me for so much of my life… I don’t know. But what I do know, is that at the end of Ten’s run, I was in love. And mid way through Eleven’s first season, I wasn’t.
/end